Top Saving Mistakes to Avoid

Top Saving Mistakes to Avoid

When there are loans to be paid and birthday gifts to be purchased, it may seem like saving money is your last priority. But in the long run, regularly contributing to your financial security pays off.

We’ve put together a list of the top mistakes to avoid when you’re building up your savings. The biggest of all? Not starting.

1. Forgetting to Make Saving Part of Your Monthly Budget

  • What we mean: Think of saving as a regular habit, like paying rent.
  • Why: If you don’t work savings into your budget, you’re likely never to do it. Nearly 40% of recently surveyed Americans reported no non-retirement savings at all. The easiest way to avoid ending up in this situation is to put a little away each month.
  • How to avoid it: Deposit your paycheck into a savings account, and from there, pay yourself with a transfer to your checking account. If you don’t see it in your checking, you won’t spend it—and you’ll get used to living on less. Or, have your HR department deposit a portion of your paycheck into savings and the other part into checking.
  • Already made this mistake? Work savings into your budget now. Make sure to send money to your savings before you do any everyday spending on groceries, entertainment, shopping and more.

2. Stashing Your Cash in a Shoebox Under the Bed—or in a CD

  • What we mean: It’s not safe to hold on to more than a couple hundred dollars in cash. But at today’s interest rates, it’s also not worth it to lock up your savings in a CDA certificate of deposit, also known as a CD, is a type of deposit account. It offers a higher interest rate than a savings account, but locks in your money—and your interest rate—for the length of the CD’s term. Withdrawing funds before your CD matures usually means a stiff penalty., which requires you to keep the money in the bank long term.
  • Why: CDs offer slightly higher interest rates, but if you need to withdraw funds early, you’ll pay a penalty that could cancel out any earned interest—and more. Plus, if you lock in interest rates when they’re rock bottom (as they are now in June 2012), you won’t be able to jump on higher rates when they inevitably start rising.
  • How to avoid it: Keep any money you might need in an emergency or the immediate future easily accessible, not trapped behind an early withdrawal penalty. Opt for a savings account: they offer similar rates to CDs these days, and are more flexible.
  • Already made this mistake? If you’ve already started building your emergency fund in a CD, don’t fret. It’s not worth it to eat the early withdrawal fee just to get out of your CD. Just open a savings account so you can continue to build your emergency fund while keeping it is easily accessible. If you’ve already amassed your full emergency fund, then there’s no need to transfer the money now. Just pray you don’t need it until after you can withdraw it without penalty.


3. Buying Any Financial Products You Don’t Understand

  • What we mean: Keep saving simple.
  • Why: Complex products like annuities are a common pitch to hopeful investors. But they typically involve high fees, and you might have a hard time accessing your money when you need it.
  • How to avoid it: Be wary of words that sound too good to be true. Example? "Risk-free." Before you build up your emergency fund, don’t worry about putting your money to work. Your savings account should be simple, safe and liquid.
  • Already made this mistake? Try to wiggle out of an annuity and you’ll find yourself tangled in a web of penalties and taxes. If you’re already invested, ride it out until the period for “surrender charges” (for cashing out early) is over, usually from six to eight years after you first purchased the annuity. You’ll want to talk this move over with the annuity company, and maybe even bring in a financial planner to help.


Get started with a free financial assessment.

4. Keeping Your Savings and Checking Accounts at the Same Bank

  • What we mean: Keep the account you use for saving far away from the one you use for everyday spending.
  • Why: Having all your accounts under one roof can make tapping your savings tempting—and too easy. Plus, by sticking to just one bank, you could be losing out on better deals.
  • How to avoid it: Just open your accounts at different banks. For your checking account, look for everyday convenience. For savings, interest rates matter. For both, look carefully at fees. Also, don’t forget smaller institutions. According to a survey by, online banks and medium-sized banks offer the highest interest rates.
  • Already made this mistake? Start shopping—for banks, that is. Websites like and can tell you what different banks are offering and how they’ll fit your needs. Use our step-by-step guide to choose a new bank account.

5. Being Seduced by Introductory Rates

  • What we mean: When it comes to special offers, look beyond the promotional period.
  • Why: Many banks offer high introductory savings rates to reel in new customers. But they apply only up to a point, after which rates can plummet.
  • How to avoid it: It’s fine to take advantage of sweet promotions. Just be sure to do the math so you really do get a good deal. At today’s interest rates, cash sign-up bonuses (often $50 or $100) might net you higher returns than teaser rates.
  • Already made this mistake? If the promo period is over, and you’re unimpressed with your new, lower rates, switch accounts! Remember to read the fine print when you’re signing up for the next one.

6. Keeping All Your Savings in One Bucket

  • What we mean: Divide your savings into sub-accounts with specific purposes, i.e. “emergency fund” or “car.”
  • Why: If your savings are lumped into a single account, it’s easy to accidentally spend what should be for emergencies.
  • How to avoid it: Setting up separate accounts for goals like travel or home renovation will let you know if you can afford to attend a destination wedding without raiding your emergency fund or jeopardizing your trip home for the holidays.
  • Already made this mistake? Set savings goals, and funnel your existing funds into sub-accounts for each one. Your bank should let you do that for free. If not, look for a new one, because this feature is important! The account holding your emergency fund should take priority as you divvy up your savings.

7. Saving Without a Goal

  • What we mean: Keep a dollar target for each savings goal—and a timeline for reaching it.
  • Why: Not having a firm goal for savings can help you justify dipping into savings, i.e., “I know I need a lot of money for my down payment, not sure how much exactly, but since I already have $15,000 toward it, it couldn’t hurt to take out $2,000 …” Not having a concrete number or deadline could also push you over budget, if you don’t know how much you need to set aside every month to reach your goal.
  • How to avoid it: Creating a deadline for how much you should set aside each month, and knowing that dollar figure, will help you see whether you really can afford to save that much in that time period. Calculate how much you need to save in how much time to reach your goal with this calculator. Stick to your budget while you’re saving so you don’t go into the red for a week at the beach.
  • Already made this mistake? If you have general savings accounts, but no goals attached, figure out how much you want to accrue in each account. Your emergency fund should contain six months’ worth of living expenses. For other goals, use our calculator to see how much you need to set aside, and head into the Budgeting Tool to see if that will work with your budget. Remember that each goal should have its own account.

8. Cashing Out Your Savings to Pay Off Debts

  • What we mean: Save and pay back your loans at the same time.
  • Why: According to a recent poll, paying down debt is the most common financial goal for 2012 among employed Americans—especially for women. It may seem counterintuitive to owe high-interest debt while you have a few grand in the bank. But if you drain your savings to pay off a loan, one unexpected emergency could push you back into debt.
  • How to avoid it: Come up with a timeline to pay off your high-interest debt, but keep stashing away a small amount each month. If an emergency comes up, you’ll appreciate having a comfortable cushion to fall back on.
  • Already made this mistake? Start rebuilding your emergency fund immediately, which should be easier now that monthly debt payments are out of the picture. Then, don’t touch it, unless…

9. Dipping Into Your Emergency Fund Unless Your Health, Job, Living Situation or Financial Security Is at Stake

  • What we mean: Your emergency fund is off limits for that much-needed vacation, that new laptop you need or a down payment on a home. Use it only if you lose your job, have an unexpected medical expense or face another true emergency.
  • Why: According to, only one in four Americans have savings to cover at least six months of expenses. If the unexpected happens, you want to fall back on your savings, not a credit card.
  • How to avoid it: Separate your needs and wants. It’s OK to use your emergency fund to repair your car so that you can get to work—that’s what it’s there for. Buying a newer model, though, is definitely a want.
  • Already made this mistake? Now that you’ve already used your emergency funds for a non-emergency, work again to build up a financial safety net of six months net pay (the post-deductions income you actually see each month).

10. Falling Victim to “Lifestyle Inflation”

  • What we mean: Your savings rate should keep pace with your income and lifestyle.
  • Why: As income rises, living expenses are bound to follow. What used to be an emergency fund with six months of net pay might only last five now that your income has gone up.
  • How to avoid it: If you get a raise and move to nicer digs or otherwise increase your monthly spending, increase your savings as well. Monthly essential expenses, like rent, utilities and groceries, shouldn’t add up to more than 50% of net income. If your monthly expenses increase, contribute more toward your emergency fund until you can cover six months of your new net pay.
  • Already made this mistake? Build your emergency fund back up so that you can depend on it for six months, if necessary. In the future, try to keep track of your expenses (one in five U.S. adults don’t, according to a recent survey), because saving gets harder if you’re not watching where your money is going.


Financial planning made simple.

Get your free financial assessment.

Related Tags

Get the latest in your inbox.

Subscription failed!

You're Now Subscribed!