Should I Recycle This? How to Trash 9 Items

Should I Recycle This? How to Trash 9 Items

Here’s another helpful post from our friends at MainStreet. Check it out:

If you live in a municipality with a recycling program, certain items are clearly recyclable. Newspaper? Throw it in the bin! Empty milk bottles? Sure! Empty boxes? You bet!

But other items are more dubious. Is that glass bottle really recyclable, or is it just going to be smashed into mostly useless bits? And what about plastic grocery bags?

There are a lot of misconceptions out there about what can and can’t be recycled, in large part because different municipalities have different rules about recycling–and that’s partly responsible for lower recycling rates. Nickolas J. Themelis, director of the Earth Engineering Center at Columbia University, says that in New York City, approximately 18% to 19% of total waste is recycled. Under ideal conditions, that number would be closer to 38%, which means about half of recyclable material isn’t getting recycled.

Meanwhile, well-meaning people are throwing materials in their recycling bin that shouldn’t be there, which has the potential to gum up the works at the recycling center. So what should and shouldn’t be recycled? While your own local laws will vary, here are a few general guidelines.

1. Plastic Bags

Verdict: Recycle them–but don’t put it in the bin.

Perhaps inspired by visions of plastic bags clogging up landfill and suffocating wildlife, some people are inclined to put their plastic bags in the recycling bin. Others will use it as a container for recyclables like bottles, assuming that it’s all one big recyclable plastic family.

But that’s not the case, says Jennifer Berry, a spokeswoman for, a directory of recycling information. She says that plastic bags are almost never accepted in municipal recycling programs, and that their presence can even cause a temporary shutdown at the processing center.

That doesn’t mean you have to put them in the trash, though. Many grocery stores will have programs in place for taking back their old grocery bags. And Earth911 lets you search for businesses in your area that take back certain types of plastic bags for recycling – just check the number on the bag to see whether it’s acceptable for recycling.

2. ‘Shiny’ Paper Products

Verdict: Put them in the recycling bin.

Berry says that one common misconception is that “shiny” or mixed-material paper products are off-limits for recycling–for instance, glossy magazines or envelopes with a plastic viewing window. However, she says that those extraneous materials can be removed in the process.

3. Pizza Boxes

Verdict: Throw them in the garbage.

One thing that can’t be removed in the recycling process? Grease.

That’s why you generally shouldn’t put a greasy pizza box in the paper recycling – or any other paper product that’s “contaminated” with food waste, including paper plates.

“The recycling process uses water, and everyone knows the old adage about oil and water not mixing,” Berry says.

While we’re not suggesting throwing away perfectly good cardboard and paper, putting greasy paper in the recycling bin will do more harm than good.

4. Glass Bottles

Verdict: Get the deposit.

Most municipal recycling programs accept glass bottles. There’s just one problem, says Themelis: Between when you put a bottle in the recycling bin to when it gets to the processing center, there are a lot of opportunities for it to get smashed to bits, which in turn means that other recyclable materials in your bin get contaminated with broken glass.

The solution? Recycle it yourself at a local collection center, especially if you live in one of the 11 states that will give you a nickel or a dime for turning in empty bottles.

5. Single-Use Batteries

Verdict: Throw them in the garbage.

While most people aren’t throwing batteries in the recycling bin, it might come as a surprise that they should be tossed in the trash. Aren’t there dangerous chemicals in there that should be properly disposed of or recycled?

Not anymore. According to the Berry, single-use batteries (like the ones you’d use to power a TV remote, for instance) no longer contain any kinds of environmental toxins. While there are some programs in place that let you mail in the batteries to be disassembled, she says the economic benefit is generally not great enough to justify the effort. Just toss them in the trash.

6. Rechargeable Batteries (And the Gadgets They Come In)

Verdict: Find a taker.

Don’t toss your old phone or its rechargeable battery in the trash or the recycling bin, as it can contain toxic metals. Instead, find a retailer to take it off your hands. Berry notes that retailers like Best Buy and RadioShack both have programs that let you turn in your old cellphone or battery, regardless of where you got it. And there are also organizations like Cell Phones for Soldiers that let you donate your still-working phone to someone who needs it more.

Of course, if your old phone or MP3 player still works, you have another option: Sell it to someone. The gadget gets reused, no toxins end up in the environment and you pocket a little bit of cash.

7. Metal

Verdict: Put it in the recycling bin.

Themelis says that one of the biggest factors in determining whether something is recyclable is what sort of market there is for the material. Since different materials have different economic value, there won’t always be a market in your area for all recyclable materials.

But as a general rule, there’s almost always a market for your metal, with Themelis noting that recycled metal and aluminum products fetch a high price and are thus accepted across the board. As such, you should always feel free to toss your cans in the recycling bin.

And don’t worry about food residue or paper labels–Berry says that those are easily removed during the recycling process.

8. Pill Bottles

Verdict: Put them in the recycling bin.

“Medicine containers or pill bottles are commonly overlooked as recyclable,” explains a spokesperson for Recyclebank, a company that lets you earn points for recycling. “The easiest and most common plastics to recycle, they can become fiberfill for winter coats, sleeping bags and life jackets. It can also be used to make bean bags, rope, car bumpers, tennis ball felt, combs, cassette tapes, sails for boats, furniture and, of course, other plastic bottles.”

That’s a lot of stuff. Toss your pill bottles in the bin, but consider taking the label off first if it’s a prescription–if someone finds it, you don’t want them knowing what medicine you’re taking.

9. Snack Wrappers

Verdict: Throw them in the garbage.

Not only is that bag from your chips probably covered in grease, it’s also not made of recyclable material, as a general rule.

“The coating on candy bar wrappers, pretzel bags, frozen food boxes and juice boxes–to name a few–cannot be recycled due to the blend of materials and tendency for these wrappers to be made out of non-cellulosic materials (not plant-based), which makes recycling difficult,” notes Recyclebank.

More From MainStreet and LearnVest

Not what they claim to be: Manufacturers use "greenwashing" to sell you products.
Cleaners don't have to be toxic! These are the best green cleaning products for your buck.
Reduce your carbon footprint (and your bills) with Cut Your Costs Bootcamp.


Financial planning made simple.

Get your free financial assessment.

Related Tags

Get the latest in your inbox.

Subscription failed!

You're Now Subscribed!