Study Finds Women More Stressed By Bad News Than Men Are


Turn off the nightly news.

The results of a new study suggest that all the negative news in the media stresses women out more than it does men. Even worse, we remember details of unhappy news events better.

How stressful.

Researchers from the University of Montreal recently set out to figure out how negative news affects stress levels. For the study, the researchers divided 60 men and women into four groups to read news stories and then measured their cortisol levels–the higher the level of the hormone, the more likely the participants were stressed.

One group of men and one group of women read neutral news stories (the opening of a new park), while the other set of gender-segregated groups read negative stories (murders and accidents).

Sonia Lupien, Director of the Centre for Studies on Human Stress at the University of Montreal, describes the method. “When our brain perceives a threatening situation, our bodies begin to produce stress hormones that enter the brain and may modulate memories of stressful or negative events.”

After the first test, the participants completed stress-inducing tasks involving memory and intellect, and were measured again for indications of stress. The next day, the participants discussed the news stories with the researchers, who found that women who read negative news stories were more stressed by the memory and intellect tasks than those women who read neutral stories.

A second pattern was observed among women: Those who read stories about accidents and murders remembered more about them than those who read neutral stories. Interestingly enough, neither the level of stress nor the heightened memory was observed among the male participants.

The researchers trace the observed gender difference back to evolutionary factors. According to that theory, women have an innate interest in the survival of their offspring, making them more sensitive to potentially threatening situations.

And what does this mean for our everyday lives? It’s no news to most of us that reading about a murder–or opening an outstanding bill, or answering a call from a debt collector–is stressful. The key is in how we handle it: Do we give in, or do we take control?

  • Tara Sophia Mohr

    The study is fascinating – but this seems to be an unfounded negative interpretation of it. In my view – the fact that women are stressed by murders, by the problems in our world is a very good thing and a very sane thing. It points to why we need women watching the news, feeling the painful realities of what is happening in the world, and translating that stress into speaking up and into action. It’s no surprise to me that women find the consequences of our still-patriarchal culture to be distressing and disturbing.  - Tara Mohr