My goal for my emergency fund is about 15,000 and I am just under 20% there and saving $300/month (for now - I hope to pare my budget down little by little and increase my weekly transfer amount accordingly). My student loans are roughly $720/month (51K over 13 different loans with different interest rates) and rent is $650/month (both non-negotiable for now).
Should I be putting any extra money towards my emergency fund? Or should I be chipping away at my loans?
Assuming you have 3K saved, I would start putting more towards your loans assuming your job is pretty stable and the interest rate on your loans is more than 3%. You could probably cover 3 months or more of expenses with the emergency fund you have now, and its likely in a savings account or CD where you aren't earning much in interest. So really, you are just losing money in interest by holding on to a such large pot. If it were me, I would continue to save $100 a month towards the savings but the extra $200 towards the loans. No reason you can't work on both at the same time!
I never thought of it that way... to be honest the 3K is only about a month and a half- so I'll keep saving until I hit the 6K/3month mark (should be easier after taxes come in) and I'll shift my spending to focus more on the loans. I'm trying my best to throw an extra $20/paycheck, but with my other expenses it's kind of hard right now.
I do have a stable job, but it's in a sector of the economy that is uneasy, so it's as stable as it can be. My loans are ALL over 3% :/ with one at 9.265%. Does anyone have experience with asking Sallie Mae to lower interest rate?
First of all, it looks like you are doing great already and that you are just looking to fine-tune your personal finance strategy. I wholeheartedly applaud you :)
I have a degree in finance (and the student loans that came with that deal), so I take a more technical approach to these types of situations. Allocating your income involves examining how you are equipped to deal with financial risks, should they happen.
It's going to vary from individual to individual. Three major things to consider, and that you have already considered to some degree, are 1) your "real" financial situation; 2) how risky maintaining student loans is to your lifestyle; and 3) your health insurance.
What's your real financial situation? As your job/income is stable, this is more of a people matter for you. If your financial situation became precarious, do you have people who will step in to help you financially until you get back your feet? If yes, then the emergency fund becomes less of a priority. If no, or if you do not want to accept help, then your emergency fund becomes very important.
Next, consider the risk of having student loans. The risk is the possibility of encountering a financially hazardous situation that will render you unable to cover your monthly payments (so, if your monthly payments are higher, your risk will be higher than someone who has lower monthly payments). Do you want to maintain low-grade financial risk and pay more interest in the long term so that you can use your money in different ways now, or would you rather eliminate the risk as quickly as you can?
Personally, I have no problem living like a pauper so that I can eliminate the risk as quickly as I can. Also, my monthly payments are higher than yours, so I currently face more risk than you do. But I've always kind of lived like a pauper so it's not really a downgrade in lifestyle for me.
Finally, is your health insurance plan comprehensive? If it doesn't protect you that much, you will want to put more money into the emergency fund to compensate.
Again, I really think that you are doing fantastic as it is, and fine-tuning it a little here or there is only going to help you out a little because you are already doing so great.
Thanks for the response, Cay. This is truly more of a fine-tuning and optimization for my finance strategy - trying to get the most out of what I have.
Right now, if my financial situation became precarious, I don't have anyone to fall back on (I actually am in this moral limbo where I'm semi supporting my mom & brother through the remainder of a divorce settlement and even though I desperately want to move out, I'd have huge amounts of guilt and they would lose their home).
The risk of my loans is one I would like to mitigate ASAP, but am not sure if it should be at the expense of my emergency fund.
I'm already living like a pauper (for the most part). It becomes tough when I am asked to (unexpectedly to me) throw some money on a bill for mom or have to run family groceries with sirloin steak on the menu. Refusing to purchase certain items would lead to greater tensions at home where there already are some, partly me being 22, working FT and trying to my myself my priority over certain aspects of family living (and I'm NOT trying to sound really selfish, but it gets trying when Mom is always going out with her boyfriend and I'm guilted into staying home with my brother, who can certainly be alone for the night - sorry for the vent lol) :/ I HATE limbo!
I will need to double check my health insurance. I believe it's pretty comprehensive with a "manageable" deductible.
I realize that this matter is really over an extra $50/ month or so, but hey $50 now can mean less in debt/ more in savings down the line, right?
Spmcavoy I'm dealing with literally the same exact issue. I pay over $800 in student loans plus my car payment, commuting expenses, living expenses and I stll live at home so I'm not paying rent. I plan on moving in with my boyfriend soon which is making me a bit anxious because everything that I save from my paycheck will be going towards rent.
I think I agree with you that the emergency fun needs to be saved up a bit before we can throw any extra money into our student loans. I keep looking for articles about this issue and haven't really been able to find too much so I was so happy to come across your post.
Oh one more thing that I didn't mention earlier. I once attended a financial advisor presentation after law school where the advisor said if you are anxious to pay down your loans but have a decent interest rate, you might want to consider just saving that money in a separate account and not sending in the extra payments. Her thinking was that it actually takes a lot of money and therefore time to make a significant dent in your loan balance. Your priorities may change (you may need/want a house, car, kid) and for any of those things you may need cash for the payment or need to borrow again at a higher rate. Since you can never get the cash back from an early loan payment, she was encouraging you to stay liquid to provide additional flexibility.
@Spmcavoy, This is the perfect place to vent. I think family expectations about money/spending are always hard. Perhaps you can set a budget with your mom about how much you can contribute and then politely refuse any requests beyond that.
@FLady, it's not the expenses are exorbitant or uncalled for, they just aren't as regular as I'd like them to be, therefore I forget to budget for them. And knowing me, any "refusing" would not work out well - my mother has an awesome power that would lead to tensions, passive manipulation and ultimately me caving in. lol I can't wait to move out! (Hopefully within the next 12 months!)
I would really like to thank you for your thoughtful response. It is really something to take into consideration!
Join the Discussion
Please log in or become a member (it's free!) to reply to a discussion.