Money Mayhem: Finders Isn’t Keepers in the Lottery

Libby Kane
Posted

LearnVest always seeks to educate and inform, but every once in a while, a financial matter hits the headlines and makes us go, “Huh.” Sometimes it even provides us a lens to learn about ourselves. In that spirit, from bad money decisions to financial lessons worth millions, consider our Money Mayhem your source of financial edu-tainment.

This is the tale of two Sharons.

The first, Sharon Duncan of Arkansas, bought a lottery ticket. She scanned it at a store, was told it wasn’t the winning number, and threw it away in a nearby trash can.

The second, Sharon Jones, later came by and picked up a handful of lottery tickets from the trash (something she often did), including the one discarded by Duncan. She scanned them, and lo and behold, Duncan’s ticket won her $1 million.

Sort of.

Although Jones started spending the money on gifts and a new truck, a judge says that the $1 million belongs to Duncan, who originally purchased the ticket. Jones, who doesn’t get the money, has hired a lawyer to fight for it, and said lawyer is described in HuffPost Money: “The attorney argued that people shouldn’t be allowed to throw items away and then say, ‘ooh, I want to un-abandon it.’”

Quite.

Anyway, there’s some more confusion surrounding the exact time a “Do Not Take” sign was posted on the unfortunately located trash can.

Lesson: Don’t discard your lottery tickets—which you haven’t bought anyway, because that money went to your IRA—in one piece, ripe for the taking from passersby.

Also, losers weepers.

So tell us: Who should get the money and why?

  • maesaysdoit

    I think the person that picked them out of the trash. BUT, this is assuming that she/he is not in collusion with the store clerk that told the actual purchaser that her/his ticket was not a winner. That store clerk could be watching what the purchaser does. If they throw it away, they then alert a 3rd party to pick the trash for the ticket; then the two of them split the winnings. And the store clerk is never found to be involved. The scam works or it doesn’t.  When you buy, lottery tickets, it is best to check them online or at a location where you personally have access to the ticket checking machine. But never throw them away. When you do finally win, you can claim all the losing tickets on your tax form.