Are We Workaholics, or Over-Worked?

Libby Kane
Posted

Workaholism is bad, right?

Wrong. A new study from the Rouen Business School in France found that workaholism, instead of being just a common descriptive trait of absent parents and that neurotic boss you used to have, can actually be a good thing.

The idea is that as long as workaholics are self-motivated and not damaging their physical or mental health, and are benefiting their company or pleased with their accomplishments, workaholism can be energizing. Stress, when it leads to these results, is considered a “positive motivator.”

Late Nights at the Office Still Aren’t Recommended

The study draws a line between being a workaholic and being over-worked. Over-working comes from external, negative motivators such as “the need for overtime pay or a cruel boss,” and “turns stress into distress.” That’s particularly interesting, because the U.S. is commonly recognized as the most over-worked country in the world.

While the study’s authors insist that the work-life balance of workaholics is fine—just a different balance than their co-workers—we can’t help but be skeptical. It’s often hard to distinguish whether we’re internally or externally motivated in our approach to a job, which makes it similarly difficult to tell “different balance” from “unbalanced.”

So, Am I a Workaholic, or Over-Worked?

Last time you stayed late at the office or worked from home all weekend, what was your reasoning? (Of course, your answers don’t mean you are one or the other, but they will give you an idea what to look out for.)

“It had to get done—and I rocked it.”
“I knew that my work would make a difference, and I was right.”
“My boss really needed it done, and I really need her to be happy.”
“That overtime pay was really going to come in handy.”

If you answer either of the first two, you were motivated internally, which is a characteristic of workaholics.
If you answered either of the second two, you were motivated externally, which is a characteristic of people who are over-worked.

Work-life balance can often be tweaked by refusing to let bills and chores pile up or making time at work as efficient as possible, so time off the clock is also off the grid. We recognize that the lines between work and life are often blurry, but here at LearnVest, we’re all about maintaining your physical and mental health right alongside your financial.

Happy Friday!

How do you find balance? Share your tips in LV Discussions.

Posted in:
  • http://michievouskitty.blogspot.com Stephanie

    Hmmm… I feel like I fall somewhere in between.  I generally only put in my 40 hours at my full-time day job, but I also work part-time as a librarian (the goal is to eventually make that my full-time job).  I’ll take all the hours I can get there, because I really and truly enjoy it and want to get as much experience as I can.  But I do also like making the extra money, and I’d be lying if I said it wasn’t a motivating factor in taking an extra shift even if I’m tired.  ;-)

  • Gbc3

    This article makes it seem like people are overworked by choice.  I am overworked because my company keeps cutting staff and giving the remaining people more work to do.  I can’t get my work done in 40 hours a week, but that’s not a choice.  And I’m certainly not earning overtime pay for it, either.

  • http://onlearningtolivewell.tv/ Leah Spinrad

    I work a lot, and I feel like I have a balance of both- but I lean toward the “workaholic” side. I work my full time job 30-45 hours a week which is managing residential accounts for a cleaning company, so I am out and about most of the time, cleaning houses, training workers, and doing consultations. I love my boss and so I am willing to do more, but I feel really great about everything I do there. My other job is 3 weekends a month, I took that on so that I could meet my financial goals in 2012. Then I have my dream project which is a wellness and lifestyle blog focused on cooking and simple fine living, onlearningtolivewell.tv . I still have time to spend with my friends and my sweetie, and we go away that one weekend a month to visit with friends and family in the area. I meditate and exercise and sleep at least 8 hours a night. I am sure if I had children the whole thing would be different. But I am very happy with my life right now

  • Kris

    I have been trying to make my time at work and at home more efficient for as long as I have been working.  Recently I began reading “The Power of Full Engagement” which has caused me to think much more about my use and recuperation of energy. I have been able to use my time management strategies more effectively as a result.