From Orthodontists To Ob-Gyns: The Doctor-Rating Sites To Trust

Posted

Being responsible with your money isn’t just about savings accounts and higher salaries—it’s also about thinking ahead. Going to the doctor for regular checkups will almost certainly save you money in the long run (to say nothing about the physical and emotional savings).

According to the American Academy of Family Physicians, the nation would save $67 billion if every American used a primary care physician.

But…Going To The Doctor Requires Actually Having A Doctor.

In an ideal world, you’d even like your doctor. We still find that referrals from a friend, family member, or coworker are best when looking for a physician we’ll like. Sometimes, we ask other doctors we respect for their referrals, since they’re likely to suggest other smart, competent colleagues.

If All Else Fails, The Internet Can Save You.

First, a disclaimer: Reviews on doctor rating sites can sometimes be really bombastic. Nearly every doctor will anger a patient at some point by doing something like denying a prescription she requests, and the most disgruntled tend to be the ones who submit ratings. Jeremiah Frank, M.D., who has a private family practice in Massachusetts, says: “Several of my friends and colleagues, whom I consider to be excellent doctors, have surprisingly vitriolic reviews about them.” All the same, the newfangled ways of the internet can be a great resource—as long as you take reviews with a grain of salt.

There are tons of ratings sites out there, so we surveyed the most popular of them to figure out which seem worth our time. Strengths and weaknesses of each site will vary by the kind of search you perform, but we looked up three different docs on each, all with different specialties and in different urban/small town settings. Here’s what we found:

The Winners.

Far and away, our favorite was Vitals.com because it’s easy to use, searchable along lots of different, useful guidelines, has more reviews than many of the other sites, and those reviews are generally good quality. We also liked ZocDoc because it’s pioneering an OpenTable-like way to make appointments online, but we found it lacking in terms of the doctors it serves and the reviews it houses. We still have a sweet spot for Yelp, so we’re staying tuned and hoping that it becomes a more reputable source for doctors in the future.

Pay It Forward.

Think of every time you’ve wished for a good medical recommendation, and prevent someone else from feeling the same way by writing reviews (positive or negative) of your doctors. Consider it community service.

Posted in: , ,
  • Deb

    Very helpful post! Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/alexavontobel alexavontobel

    I was just looking for a Dr. and had it on my schedule to make an appt today. thank you!

  • AGM

    What about Angie’s list? I’m surprised it wasn’t mentioned here.

    • http://twitter.com/amkade Allison Kade

      Hi AGM,nnThanks for the suggestion! To tell the truth, in our sleuthing around to find the best sites, we never came across Angie’s List. Why do you like it? nnI just checked it out right now, and I could be wrong, but it looks like you can’t search directly for a doctor and that you may need an account to even look for reviews? Is that true? Admittedly, I don’t know my way around that site too well yet.nnThanks for sharing an additional resource!nnBest,nAllison KadenDeputy Editor, LearnVest

  • Kennonmarie

    What about healthgrades.com? What did you guys think about that? nnOddly enough I found that the hardest part isn’t even about finding a Doctor you like or has good reviews, it is getting in to see a doctor at all! I am insured (have been my whole life…I’m very lucky, I know) and this past fall when I came down with the flu my teacher told me I was required to get a doctors note (this is also a stupid policy b/c do you really want a kid with the flu sitting in your class? That is exactly how I got the flu in the first place!) Anyhoo, I called AT LEAST 15 different doctor’s offices. I tried to get in to see my random primary care dr, but he was gone or something. I proceeded to call around and NO ONE would take me. I was dumbfounded. I had great insurance coverage, I was sick, and I needed a doctor – Yet no one would see me? In between feeling super lousy and really depressed I realized that my college has a “nurses office”…I called them, they were so nice, they saw me, gave me a doctor’s note, and told me to keep doing what I was doing; staying home, resting, drinking water. nnAnyhoo, I just think that rather than worrying about ratings I find myself more worried about finding someone who will actually take me! =) n

    • http://twitter.com/amkade Allison Kade

      Hi Kennonmarie,nnGreat point about HealthGrades–we actually omitted that site on purpose because we found that Insider Pages imports most of its info from HealthGrades, anyway, so we thought they were a bit too similar to mention both. nnAnd, yeah, it can definitely be tough to get in to see a doctor on short notice for something like being actively sick, especially if you haven’t been a long-term patient. In my experience, if you’re in college, school-related health services tend to be the way to go, almost aways, if only because of the convenience and ease of use.nnThanks for weighing in and I’m glad you’re feeling better!nnAllison KadenDeputy Editor, LearnVest

  • eB

    In Atlanta the best source is, hands down, Kudzu.com. Customers value Kudzu reviews and I have seen businesses change the way they practice because of feedback they received on Kudzu. When I go with the highest-rated business I am very rarely disappointed, although I am very careful to read both the positive and negative reviews and make a decision on all of the information available. My OB-gyn and my dentist are both number one in Atlanta. The funny thing is I found them pre-Kudzu, so I would be seeing them anyway.